Six on Saturday: Spring in Our ‘Novel’ Garden

Hybrid daffodil

When we first moved to this garden nearly 12 years ago, we were delighted to find daffodils blooming our first spring, in a lush mass across a bank in the front yard.  We watched in wonder as their buds opened, revealing their varied forms and colors. 

Our next door neighbors, an English couple, also love daffies and plant a fresh lot of bulbs each fall to add to their springtime display.  Daffodils are heirloom plants, blooming for many decades after they are planted.  They divide each summer and sometimes their seeds are spread around, allowing for natural hybrids and unpredictable spread. Their bright yellows, whites and golds light up our woodlands before the first buds of Forsythia or wild deerberries begin their bloom.

This is an heirloom daffodil popular in the 17th Century. Double Van Scion, or Guernsey Double Daffodil c. 1620 England

Popular in Europe in the 16th Century, early colonists brought Narcissus bulbs to Virginia sewn into the hems of skirts and coats.  They were a bit of home brought with them as they settled this wild land.

Our garden was carved out of this woodland when our home was built in the mid-1960s on previously undeveloped land, rolling hills and ravines on the banks of College Creek.  Before the developers bought it, it had belonged to a local hospital as an investment property, having been donated some years prior by a logging company. 

I’m told that all of the native trees had been cleared around Williamsburg by the Revolutionary War.  I’ve seen historic maps of the area between the James and York rivers, cleared of forest, dating to the late 18th Century.  Although our area was settled by the English and Germans in the 17th Century, before their arrival and in those earliest years of settlement it was still hunted by the native peoples who inhabited coastal Virginia.

When we first came here, the garden we inherited was already a ‘novel’ garden.  That is a term new to me, but means that the natural flora of the land has been disturbed and ‘exotic’ plants brought in to replace the native plants that once grew in a spot.  The two earlier owners of our home were both avid gardeners.

I’ve been transplanting seedling Hellebores for many years to hold our steep bank. Although Hellebore is native to Europe and Asia, it naturalizes here easily. Tough and evergreen, it fills an important niche in our garden that no native plant will fill.

We found Asian Camellia and Forsythia shrubs planted under the native oaks and red maples.  We discovered European daffodils planted under the native dogwoods and redbud trees, already supporting a thick skirt of dark green European ivy.

There was an Asian Jasmine vine planted on the railing near the back door, Japanese mophead Hydrangeas in a hedge by the garage, Chinese hollies, a hybrid rose, various fruit trees, and Asian Hibiscus shrubs everywhere.  I found it charming.

When we were ready to plant, we visited local garden centers and read nursery catalogs in search of favorite plants. 

The American philosophy of gardening from the 17th Century until very recently has been to find, exploit and plant every useful and beautiful plant that will grow in the climate.  Horticultural explorers have looked for useful and profitable plants on every continent and in every climate; and still do.  Ordinary folks like us can grow shrubs and herbs, vegetables, vines, trees and flowers from any part of the planet, all jumbled together in the same acre of land.

Hydrangea quercifolia, Oakleaf Hydrangea, is native to our area of Virginia. The flowers below, Chinese Paperbush, fill the garden with perfume.

But should we? 

That is the intriguing question I’ve been grappling with, lately.  The more deeply I explore the importance of planting site natives, that support the many insects, animals and other plants already living in a region, the more I realize how much I really don’t know, and don’t understand, about the ecology of our garden. 

The issue is much larger than our acre.  The issue is much larger than our neighborhood, or state, or even our continent.  The entire world may now be a garden of sorts, touched by man for human purposes, with little wilderness left.  But when we look around and consider the changes our hands have made, is it ‘good?’

A plant lives in complex relationships with the soil cradling its roots, the other plants growing nearby, the insects that chew its leaves or pollinate its flowers, and the insects and birds that spread its seeds.  It is the relationships, and the community created by a collection of plants growing in proximity to one another that either support the greater ecology of an area or contribute to its demise.  Issues of soil health, hydration management, species support or extinction, and perhaps even climate change all depend in large part on how we steward the land we own in our private and our public spaces.

Native Hazel, Corylus americana blooms in late winter, offering these wispy male catkins to ornament our forest garden.

Benjamin Vogt, a horticultural professional, ecologist and author has me squirming a bit as I read his 2017 book A New Garden Ethic: Cultivating Defiant Compassion for an Uncertain Future.  

Many of the plants I love to grow are European, Asian, or from parts of North American beyond Virginia.  Many of the site natives I perhaps should be growing in our garden don’t have the same appeal.  As I’ve planted more and more native plants, or allowed them to take root and spread in this garden, I often find them aggressive.  They crop up in unexpected places.  Their plan runs counter to mine.

Plants I pulled out as ‘weeds’ during our first years here, I later learned, after a bit of research, are site native wildflowers.  My knowledge of native plants grows a bit more each year as I question what grows around me.  But most of these plants are tough to find, at least in their ‘species’ form, in any catalog or shop.

The whole conversation brings us back to that fundamental questions: “Why do we garden?”  “Who is the garden for?”  Is it for the human who makes it, or for the larger environment and web of local life that depends upon it for sustenance?

There are as many answers to those questions as there are individuals pondering them, discussing them.  Vogt takes many of my own arguments for growing a ‘novel’ garden, one mixing native plants with hybrids and imports, and takes them apart piece by piece.  I squirm, and keep reading out of curiosity and a deep knowing that on some essential level he understands the bigger issues more intimately than do I.   

I’m still enjoying our daffodils, with their bright and optimistic blooms.  Even as I’m watching flats of native oaks I sowed in fall for signs of growth, I’m also preparing to plant Caladiums, native hundreds of miles to our south.  Caladiums do nothing for the local wildlife, which is part of why I love growing them.  They survive the grazers. 

I have decades of training in what to grow and how to grow it based on a novel garden filled with beautiful plants to please the human senses. 

Now, I’m trying to learn to shift my sensibilities to garden more for the planet, and for the support of our local ecosystem, than for my own very human desires.  The reward for growth and change comes in the flutter of butterfly wings and the flight of hummingbirds.  High wages for rewarding work.

These recently planted pots hold only native plants. Heuchera, the only plants now visible, are hybrids of American natives and feed early pollinators. Ostrich ferns will emerge next, followed by Liatris spicata in early summer. Williamsburg Botanical Garden.

With appreciation to The Propagator who hosts Six on Saturday each week.




  1. A very interesting read. Thank you. While appreciating the native flora, gardeners will always seek out something new, different and interesting for their gardens and I believe these introductions, as long as they are not invasive, add to the diversity of an area, enriching it.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Paddy, I agree with you, from personal experience. Every winter I’m drawn to the catalogs and articles describing the ‘new introductions’ for the year, and every May am searching for certain ones at my garden center. I love to grow things out and see what they will do. Life teaches that it is difficult to know in advance what will be invasive, where. Sometimes it takes decades for a plant to fall out of favor. What delights the gardener might not also support or enhance the local bees, butterflies and birds. Should we be concerned by that? That is the question Vogt challenges me with. Thanks for visiting, commenting, Paddy. Enjoy the day!

      Liked by 1 person

      • You are gardening in an area of old woodland and I imagine that your garden plant introductions would extend the range of material available to pollinators. Of course, if they become invasive and replace native flora, there is a problem!

        Liked by 1 person

      • When I started buying plants for my own yard, in the mid 1980s, Autumn Olive was a hot item because it supports pollinators, feeds birds, is tough and persistent. Every catalog promoted them. Now, we have learned how invasive they can become, crowding out other species. I had some appear (volunteers) in a border in this garden. I left them alone for a few years to see what they would do. Then I began pruning hard every spring to control their rampant growth. I just cut two of them back to about 4″ tall, and will do that with any others I notice this spring. Yes, they feed pollinators. But I’m going to favor the native Vacciniums cropping up in the garden and control the Elaeagnus, because they are aggressive. Sometimes flowers with the most nutritious pollen and nectar are the least impressive to the human eye. My solution is to grow a dense garden, with lots of plants, and hope that lots of different species can find what they need here to thrive. But thoughtful editing is essential.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Thank you! What a lovely garden you have. Your veggie patch is especially nice, but I’m also admiring your bank of primroses. Our favorite garden center is run by friends who moved here from Ireland about 15 years ago now. They offer primroses every spring, and so many other wonderful plants. I’ve not tried planting them here, but you are inspiring me with that lovely bank of them. Best, WG

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s